DIY Reeses Cups are one of those treats that make everyone’s eyes light up, and in this guide we’ll turn that candy-aisle favorite into a simple, customizable homemade dessert you can whip up any time. If you love playing with flavors, textures, and fun twists like Reese’s Pieces Cookies or brownie mashups, you’ll be thrilled to see how easy it is to build your own DIY peanut butter cup collection right in your kitchen.
These homemade cups are cheaper, often healthier, and endlessly tweakable: dark chocolate instead of milk, almond butter instead of peanut butter, extra protein, low sugar—the choice is yours. We’ll walk through the basic “master” recipe and then give you ideas to morph it into everything from high-protein cups to cookie-stuffed, over-the-top creations.
—
Nutritional Benefits
Homemade peanut butter cups give you control over ingredients—especially sugar, type of chocolate, and the kind of nut butter you use. Using dark chocolate (70–85%), natural peanut butter, and a small amount of unrefined sweetener can turn this from a pure candy into a more balanced treat with:
– Better fats from peanuts or other nuts
– Some protein and fiber
– Less added sugar than commercial candy
Here is an approximate nutrition snapshot for one small cup (made with dark chocolate and natural peanut butter):
| Nutrition | Per Cup (Approx.) |
|---|---|
| Calories | 180 |
| Carbohydrates | 14 g |
| Protein | 5 g |
| Fat | 13 g |
| Saturated Fat | 5 g |
| Fiber | 2 g |
| Sugar | 10 g |
| Sodium | 60 mg |
You can lower sugar with stevia-sweetened or very dark chocolate, and boost protein by adding a spoonful of protein powder to the filling.
—
Ingredients & Substitutions
Below is a simple base recipe for about 12 mini cups:
– Dark or milk chocolate chips
– Natural creamy peanut butter
– Maple syrup or honey
– A little coconut flour or almond flour (to thicken the filling)
– Pinch of salt
– Optional: vanilla extract, flaky sea salt on top
| Ingredient | Role | Possible Substitutions |
|---|---|---|
| Dark or milk chocolate chips | Forms the shell | Chocolate bars (chopped), sugar-free chocolate, white chocolate |
| Natural peanut butter | Creamy, nutty filling | Almond butter, cashew butter, sunflower seed butter |
| Maple syrup or honey | Sweetens filling, adds moisture | Agave, coconut sugar (mix into peanut butter), sugar-free syrup |
| Coconut flour | Thickens filling | Almond flour, finely ground oats, protein powder |
| Salt | Balances sweetness, boosts flavor | Omit if peanut butter is salted; use flaky salt on top |
| Vanilla extract (optional) | Adds depth and warmth | Almond extract (tiny amount) or omit |
For Healthy Reeses Cups, lean on very dark chocolate, natural nut butter with no added sugar, and a small amount of maple syrup. For Protein Reeses Cups, replace some coconut flour with your favorite vanilla or peanut butter protein powder and sweeten to taste.
—
Equipment Needed
– Mini muffin tin (metal or silicone)
– Mini paper liners (if using metal tin)
– Heatproof bowl (for melting chocolate)
– Small spoon or teaspoon
– Medium mixing bowl
– Spatula
Optional but helpful:
– Small cookie scoop for even portions
– Microwave or double boiler for gently melting chocolate
—
Step-by-Step Instructions
We’ll use a simple, no-bake method that works for classic cups, DIY Reeses Cups with fun toppings, or even crumbled Reese’s Pieces Cookies baked from your favorite recipe to sprinkle on top.
1. Prep the pan
– Line a mini muffin tin with paper liners.
– Make sure there’s enough room in your freezer or fridge for the tray.
2. Melt the chocolate
– Add chocolate chips to a heatproof bowl.
– Microwave in 20–30 second bursts, stirring between each, until just melted and smooth.
– Stir in 1–2 teaspoons of coconut oil if you want a slightly softer shell and shinier finish.
3. Make the peanut butter filling
– In a medium bowl, stir together peanut butter, a small drizzle of maple syrup or honey, a pinch of salt, and vanilla (if using).
– Add coconut flour 1 teaspoon at a time until the mixture thickens into a soft dough that holds its shape when rolled.
– For Protein Reeses Cups, swap part of the flour with protein powder and adjust sweetness as needed.
4. Create the chocolate base
– Spoon about ½ teaspoon of melted chocolate into each liner.
– Tilt or swirl the pan so the chocolate slightly coats the bottom and just up the sides.
– Chill for 5–10 minutes until set.
5. Add the filling
– Roll small balls of peanut butter filling and gently flatten into disks slightly smaller than the liner.
– Place one disk into each chocolate-lined cup, keeping a small gap around the edge so the top chocolate can seal it in.
– If you want a twist—like a Reeses Brownies mashup—press a tiny cube of brownie or a few crumbs right into the center of the filling.
6. Seal with more chocolate
– Spoon more melted chocolate over each cup, covering the filling completely and gently tapping the pan to level the tops and remove air bubbles.
– Sprinkle with flaky sea salt, chopped peanuts, or crushed cookie bits (think Reese Pieces Cookies style) if you like.
7. Chill and serve
– Refrigerate for about 20–30 minutes, or freeze for 10–15, until fully firm.
– Peel off the liners and enjoy!
—
Troubleshooting & Pro Tips
– Chocolate too thick or clumpy?
Add a small splash of coconut oil and reheat very gently, stirring often. Overheating seizes chocolate, so low and slow is best.
– Filling too runny?
Sprinkle in more coconut flour, almond flour, or protein powder a little at a time until it’s thick but still scoopable.
– Filling too dry or crumbly?
Add a teaspoon of peanut butter or a tiny drizzle of maple syrup and mix again.
– Chocolate cracking when you bite?
Use a bit more coconut oil in the chocolate and avoid very hard chilling. Move them from freezer to fridge for 10 minutes before serving.
– Want cleaner layers?
Tap the pan on the counter after adding chocolate, and chill between each layer so the lines stay sharp.
– Flavor variations (Reeces Peanut Butter Cup Ideas)
– Add a layer of jam under the filling for a PB&J cup.
– Stir cinnamon into the filling for a warm twist.
– Swirl in a little Nutella or cookie butter for a richer dessert vibe.
—
Storage & Make-Ahead Tips
– Fridge: Store in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to 2 weeks.
– Freezer: Freeze in a single layer, then transfer to a freezer bag. They keep well for up to 3 months; thaw briefly before eating so the centers get creamy again.
– Make-ahead:
– Prep the peanut butter filling balls in advance and freeze them; coat in chocolate when you’re ready.
– Melted chocolate can be gently reheated if it starts to firm up while you’re working.
Homemade cups are great for batch-prepping snacks, dessert trays, or even gifting—fill a box with classic cups, Homemade Reese’s Eggs made with the same mixture shaped by hand, and a few cookie-inspired cups for variety.
—
Conclusion
DIY Reeses Cups are incredibly simple to make, endlessly adaptable, and a fun way to satisfy cravings with ingredients you control, whether you lean toward lighter treats, protein-packed snacks, or full-on party desserts. Once you have the basic method down, you can branch out into tray bakes, stuffed desserts, and even cookie hybrids—imagine a plate that pairs these cups with chewy Reese’s Pieces Cookies or brownies for the ultimate peanut butter–chocolate spread.
If you’re craving more peanut butter inspiration like Reeses Dessert bars, creative Home Made Reese Cups variations and other twists such as Homemade Reese’s Eggs, you can explore ideas like Reese’s Pieces Cookies , Reeses Brownies , Home Made Reese Cups , Diy Reeses Cups , Healthy Reeses Cups , Reeces Peanut Butter Cup Ideas , Reeses Dessert , Reese Pieces Cookies , Protein Reeses Cups , Homemade Reese’s Eggs to build your own dessert lineup at home.
—
FAQ
1. Can I make these peanut-free?
Yes. Use sunflower seed butter or another seed butter instead of peanut butter, and check that your chocolate is made in a peanut-free facility if allergies are severe.
2. How do I make sugar-reduced or “healthy” cups?
Use very dark or sugar-free chocolate, natural unsweetened nut butter, and a minimal amount of maple syrup or a sugar-free sweetener. Thicken with coconut flour or protein powder for extra nutrition.
3. Can I use a regular muffin tin instead of mini?
Absolutely—just know they’ll be larger and richer. Increase the filling and chocolate per cup and extend the chilling time until completely set.
4. How do I get neat edges and smooth tops?
Tap the filled tray gently on the counter to smooth the chocolate, and avoid overfilling. A small spoon or squeeze bottle helps control where the chocolate goes.
5. How long can these sit at room temperature?
If your kitchen is cool, they’re fine at room temperature for a couple of hours. For best texture and food safety, store them in the fridge and only bring out what you’ll serve.
Follow me on Pinterest for more DIY Reeses Cups.
